Regular price: $24.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.95
I wanted this book the first time I learned of it's existence. Although I very much enjoyed this story, I didn't enjoy the narrative. I thought if I adjusted the speed, perhaps it would help. (I listened at 1.5x.) While this did help to speed things along, it certainly didn't fix the lack of emotion of narrator Soneela Nankani. A beautiful voice, Nankani failed to express a wide range of character emotions. An uneventful voice conveyed the same tone in shock, anger, surprise as one would use to say "hello, there." In other words, if I were narrarating an attack I would use a voice filled with fear, anger, horror. Nankani? Not so much. Also, the voices she used to identity male characters were just plain creepy. I'm more than positive that had I read the book instead of listening to an audio version, I would rate this a five star read. However, let me state a positive. I would've never pronounced the Indian tribal names correctly and Nankani's pronunciation is lyrical. Let's move on, shall we. The storyline is wonderful. Loved every moment! Adventure, misadventure, mystery, romance (a tiny bit), Indians. Lots of good stuff happening between the pages of this book. I hate to even critique the audio because I liked it so much. My opinion, this could've been enjoyed much more if read. Susanna Quiner, 18, is superstitious and considers herself lucky. Must be the turkey hen bone she keeps in her pocket. She happens to be near the edge of Thieving Forest when her families home is attacked by Indians. Unfortunately, her sisters, Beatrice, Penelope, Aurelia, and Naomi, are kidnapped by Potawatomi Indians. Susanna watches in horror as the Potawatomi tie and bound her sisters together. Then, the tribe and their prisoners disappear into Thieving Forest. Susanna vows to stop at nothing to free her sisters. She must find help and organize a search party before the Potawatomi vanish into the deep and ancient forest. But most men of Severne are farmers, out in their fields working. Who will help the Quiner sisters? Mr. and Mrs. Quiner have recently died, leaving the girls orphaned. The girls only had rach other to rely on. Susanna must find Cade Spendlove. Cade is Aurelia's betrothed and he will surely spring in to action. Perhaps his brother Seth will also he!p. Unlike their mean, drunken father, the Spendlove brothers can be trusted. Upon learning of the kidnapping, the brothers can't understand why natives would take the Quiner sisters. They've traded with them and have never had problems with natives. It doesn't make sense. Most importantly, when Mr Quiner was alive, the Potawatomi came into the Quiner's store. Sirius Quiner believed the natives were peaceful and fair. Why, then, would the Potawatomi kidnap the frightened girls? "Usually the Potawatomi take for revenge," Mary had said, looking at Old Adam. "Or to replace someone in their tribe who has died. But no battles since a long time." - Mary, THIEVING FOREST. Susanna will set off on a mission, a journey wrought with danger, through the ancient forest. On the other side of the forest, Susanna will have to summon all of her courage and strength if she is to survive the dark, unholy Great Black Swamp and the rumored evil that lurks in both. "In forest you must lose fear," Old Adam says over his shoulder. "See with all your senses. Only way to be safe." - Old Adam, THIEVING FOREST. Overall, super impressed with the writing and storyline. It's fair to say I'll be reading more of Martha Conway. Matter of fact, I'd be thrilled to once again meet up with the good folks who live in or around the edge of Thieving Forest.
Would you consider the audio edition of Thieving Forest to be better than the print version?
I enjoyed the story very much, but it was very hard to get past the narration, it almost ruined this book for me. I almost want to read the actual book and hopefully fill in some of what I missed because the narrator was so distracting (in a bad way). I could NOT get past the narrator's girl voices for these young women. Simple sentences were delivered as whiny, borderline creepy and very irritating. I understand that in some instances, the protagonist was naive, but never whiny. I think there is a really solid, beautiful story here, but it is hard to find when listening to this as an audio book. Read the real thing instead.
What was one of the most memorable moments of Thieving Forest?
The relationship between self and surroundings.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
Very poor voice-over choices for these young women in the story. It actually makes you physically uncomfortable with annoyance and anger at such odd voice choices.
If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?
A journey of redemption.
1 of 2 people found this review helpful