Regular price: $28.50
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $28.50
What would have made The Three better?
The Three is like many books in the horror/suspense genre. Its premise and character development are much stronger than the plot. As a result, the conclusion of the book feels unsatisfying relative to the investment made by the reader/listener. I think this book would be much stronger had the author figured out a way to deliver her "make you wonder" conclusion within the construct of a single narrative style. Most of the novel is spent within a book-inside-a-book done in the recounting style of World War Z. The very beginning and very end are spent in standard third-person narration. This shift is distracting and makes the ending feel a bit more like a letdown.
What was most disappointing about Sarah Lotz’s story?
The underlying question of the novel is "who or what are the Three?" The conclusion is intended to leave you going "whoa" or "what the!?!" Instead, I found myself going "meh". I do not want to spoil the ending, so it is difficult to elaborate. I believe the author's intent with the ending is to make you rethink various clues throughout the novel. Fair enough. I enjoy books that try to do this. But it is a little annoying with this book because the punchline does not really answer the underlying question. And the punchline is simply not strong enough to make you want to reflect back upon the nuances of the story.
Have you listened to any of Andrew Wincott and Melanie McHugh ’s other performances before? How does this one compare?
I was unfamiliar with the work of the narrators. They both did an excellent job.
You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?
The Three draws you in with its premise and character development. My feelings about this novel are similar to my feelings about many of Stephen King's books -- the plot and conclusion were a bit of a letdown. Like King, I think Ms Lotz could easily hit a home run with a future novel.
Any additional comments?
There is an interesting commentary in the background of this book about the potential for the Christian Right to gain control of the US government such that the American republic is radically reshaped. I think the book could have gone in a very interesting direction by exploring this idea in more detail.
8 of 8 people found this review helpful
I normally would not like a book put together like this. It is written as reading a book within a book and continually changes view points of multiple characters some significant and some just adding another small piece to the puzzle. The author with the help of some great narrators pulls this off well to make a smooth and highly interesting story. I don't want to say much to spoil the plot other than I had to listen straight through. The ending left me a little disappointed as I never really knew for sure what the kids were, it just gives you an idea of what they are but not an definitive answer. The narrators were excellent, they did so well that you could forget your listening to a book and just become immersed in it.
8 of 9 people found this review helpful