Regular price: $17.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.99
Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?
Not unless they were specifically seeking information about the Gnostics or Middle East conflict. (Not as a good novel/mystery).
What three words best describe Rick Zieff’s voice?
Not The Best (for narrating this book)
Do you think The Gnostic Mystery needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?
No, I think it needs to be slightly re-written, and decide whether it wants to be an informative textbook or a novel.
The information in this book is very interesting--I've personally always found the gnostics to have been a fascinating group--what little I've known about them. And the book does a lot to show the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as well. However, I'd have liked this better if it had been an honest non-fiction book.
The story just feels contrived--inserting some characters and plot line to be the support for an explanation of what the author knows about these subjects. The main character is supposed to be a wealthy and successful business owner, a man of little faith, who decides to go to Israel for a trip. He is fairly unrealistic-sounding and his main role appears to be to ask the questions so that someone else can give long, scholarly-sounding answers that explain the subjects the author finds interesting.
Yes, there is a plot, and it does move along, but I felt uncomfortable through it--feeling that I wanted (and would probably have liked) either a frank history book or less didactic material in favor of character development. I think the author could have written a fascinating history/current events book. So if there is a follow up--I'm hoping that's what it will be.
Author: *very* interesting information--please put it into a different form so we can read it without feeling like an elementary school child being taught material via the cover of a thinly-written story. There is much to talk about here--and I would love to read about what you know without your having to disguise it as a novel.
Possible future reader: Do not turn away from this book--it does have interesting information in it, it is a mystery story--and others may enjoy it in its present form. Please give it a try--you may feel differently than I do about it.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
What would have made The Gnostic Mystery better?
The author has some facts he finds amazing. So he has his characters say, "That's amazing!" or "Wow!" or "I never knew that!" If they are not speaking, his characters are looking shocked, astounded, stunned...Rather than make us share the author's enthusiasm, this just makes his characters seem cretinous and dull.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
Not the narrator's fault -- his accents weren't any worse than the words he was given to say.
What character would you cut from The Gnostic Mystery?
How about the distinguished professor from the world-class university who doesn't know the difference between "imply" and "infer"?