Regular price: $28.00
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $28.00
It's so strange. I just finished the book Greyhound about a 12 year old coming of age on a cross country bus trip. In that book the main character sounded like a 12 year old--the perspective and tone seemed right to me for the age. In this book the character was 13 years old but sounded and behaved as if he was in his mid thirties at least. He was out roaming and vandalizing the city at all hours. He was sarcastic, destructive and profane. Maybe it was the deeply dysfunctional family that brought out the troubled adult in him, but this wasn't a coming of age story. In addition, the book was filled with an amazing collection of unlikable characters.
Plus, I didn't find the story funny in the least. To me it was just really sad. In addition, the mystery it was suggested that the story solved in the description of the book makes no sense. If you research the theft it seems that it was solved in 1974. For me far too much suspension of disbelief was required for this book. It all seemed fantastical and totally improbable and impossible.
Even worse, the author narrated the book and I wonder if this wasn't a mistake and didn't add to the adult feeling and tone of the story. I think a professional narrator might have made a huge difference in the dynamics and the way the characters sounded.
All in all this was a disappointment. I wish I hadn't pushed myself to finish this sad book about 1970s New York City and a fractured family falling apart. Two stars only because I stuck with it until the end. Not for me.
13 of 15 people found this review helpful
Would you consider the audio edition of The Gargoyle Hunters to be better than the print version?
The audible edition of Mr. Gill's adventuresome tale frees you to multi-task and go about your day while keeping pace with his energetic thirteen year old hero. The author's passion for architecture and its elements comes through in his voice and expression as a boy encountering them for the first time. The boy's father salvages architectural elements and it is this dodgy activity that bonds them, but is in no way their salvation.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Gargoyle Hunters?
There are a number of Harold Lloyd moments. One when our hero, Griffin, in the middle of the night, at great height, is clinging to a spire in an attempt to harvest a gargoyle.
Have you listened to any of John Freeman Gill’s other performances before? How does this one compare?
This was the first performance of his that I've listened to. I can only compare it to other authors. He manages to convey the energy and enthusiasm of his thirteen year old hero consistently, start to finish. His delivery and annunciation are so professional that it's surprising that up until now he worked exclusively in print.
Who was the most memorable character of The Gargoyle Hunters and why?
Griffin is the most memorable and his sister Quigley is also memorable. These adolescents whose needs are barely met by their self-absorbed parents, manage to find their niches and mentors to hone their talents. Their survival is in their own hands.
1 of 3 people found this review helpful