Regular price: $67.20
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $67.20
What did you love best about The Complete Stories of Sherlock Holmes?
This was my very first Audible purchase, and I purchased wisely. I read Sherlock Holmes in bits and pieces while growing up because my dad was an avid fan, so getting this collection for such a bargain seemed like a great idea. Fortunately, I was right.
This collection covers a huge range of stories, most of which are excellent, some of which fall a little flat. This is, however, to be expected for such a volume of work. Some of it also feels a bit dated, also to be expected from any classic. Anyone interested in the detective mystery genre has to be familiar with Sherlock Holmes, and this particular collection is strongly recommended.
The narrator, Charlton Griffin, does an excellent job. I listened to a sample of another audiobook covering the same stories, and the narrator was rushing everything. Mr. Griffin takes his time and delivers an outstanding performance. My only point of feedback is that his American accent (as some American characters do present themselves) could use a little bit of work, and his voices for women were a little distracting until you got used to them.
Any additional comments?
My subject line says it all. I would very much like to see Audible release more massive collections like this one as bulk purchases.
17 of 17 people found this review helpful
Excellent complete collection of one of my favorite authors. Enjoyed the performance of the narrator who had a good consistent voice for various characters. The quality of the recording was excellent. If you want a complete collection of the Sherlock Holmes (shouldn't everyone have one?), this is the one for you.
25 of 27 people found this review helpful
What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?
Having the right person reading it.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
I cannot fathom why an American actor would be chosen to read such a quintessentially British book. Don't get me wrong, he has a lovely voice and makes a valiant effort at an English accent, but that doesn't help if you still use American pronunciation, e.g. on words like 'lever', 'depot', 'Cecil' and he's obviously not familiar with British place names as many of those have been pronounced incorrectly too. Worst of all something weird happens with the 'O' vowels in places so 'Holmes' has mutated into 'Hormes' and 'dog' into 'dawg'. Really, really disappointed because I love Sherlock stories.
31 of 31 people found this review helpful
Would you try another book written by Arthur Conan Doyle or narrated by Charlton Griffin?
love the author but the narrator is terrible
Who might you have cast as narrator instead of Charlton Griffin?
Any additional comments?
this narrator speeds through the text like a runaway train, he reads far too fast and the story is impossible to listen to, very disappointed. The narrator is supposed to be a professional, but he hardly pauses to breathe. I tried to listen on 0.75 speed but this simply distorted the audio. can I have my credit back please?
23 of 23 people found this review helpful
With the current "Elementary" television series being set in New York City, some may like this American accented take on the familiar Sherlock Holmes stories. I did not mind much as the performer does a good job and has a good voice, but my London-born wife could not stand it, so it will remain largely unplayed.
Excellent for long drives over many days, this version of the famous sleuth's adventures should prove popular with people in North America.