Regular price: $17.47
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.47
Customer ReviewsMost Helpful
By Jim Harris on 06-12-03
Mislabeled but good
I'd give this collection 5 stars for the stories since I love science fiction short stories, but the collection is mislabeled. The Best of Asimov's should have way more than 4 stories. The leading Hartwell & Dozois annual best of anthologies have 20+ stories, many of which appeared first in Asimov's. For this grand title of best of 2002, I'd say we deserved at least 10 stories, 12 would probably be truly representative since every year Asimov's has many stories nominated for numerous awards and the collection should contain those stories.
But to be balanced this collection is priced the same as the bi-monthly F&SF magazine Audible publishes and this volume has more than an hour more of content, which makes it more of a bargain.
Most importantly, the stories we do get are outstanding.
7 of 7 people found this review helpful
By Kennet on 05-24-07
Not the best sci-fi I've read
The four stories are highly variable in quality.
I didn't care at all for the first story, "The Clear Blue Seas of Luna." It's written in an extremely abstract manner, almost stream of consciousness. The plot is hard to follow, and fails to excite. I suspect that this story may be part of a larger body of work, but as it is presented in isolation it is simply confusing.
The second story, "Speaker for the Woodland Sea" is interesting, but doesn't really go anywhere with the plot. It's a beautifully designed, interesting world, but it doesn't really have a plot. It's just a random assortment of events.
"Candy Art" is fun and funny. My only complaint is that it falls short of delivering a solid conclusion.
"With Caeser in the Underworld" is also thoroughly enjoyable, but ultimately pointless. It left me with a number of unanswered questions, wondering if there was some foreshadowing that I was supposed to notice.
All of the narrators are excellent. They speak clearly, and at a good pace.
Ultimately, it's a good way to waste a few hours, but it is not suitable if it is to be one's first or only exposure to sci-fi short stories.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful