Regular price: $20.97
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.97
What did you like best about The American Gun Mystery? What did you like least?
Which was my favorite broken nose? That's about what asking for a favorite part of this story is like.
Least favorite has a number of contenders.
- The opening 45 minutes or so concerned the movement of people in the wild west show. None of those movements had any bearing on the case that was to follow and none of it was particularly interesting.
- Inspector Queen had an Irish Brogue accent for the only time I ever heard in the series.
- The solution to the mystery hinges on the hiding place of the gun, but don't waste time trying to work that out. You can't. No one could. The hiding place for the gun is utterly ridiculous if for no other reason than the size of the gun relative to the hiding place. Last time I lost my keys, I didn't look under the last grape in the fruit bowl for the same reason I'd never have looked for a gun where it was hidden. Physics. Things have volume.
What was most disappointing about Ellery Queen’s story?
I've never been a fan of the writing of the Queen stories. The puzzles on the other hand are usually airtight and well crafted. When you finally get the solution you feel like a complete idiot for not seeing them. The technical aspects of the puzzle goes a long way to make up for the cheesy writing.
In this case, the writing wasn't any worse than the puzzle.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
In the rest of the series, the voices and accents were kept fairly consistent. In this one, all those were tossed out. I'm willing to give the narrator the benefit of the doubt and say the director made the changes, but you'd think that if you were doing a later book in a series, you might give a listen to the earlier ones, and at least make the nationalities the same.
If this book were a movie would you go see it?
No. Well, maybe. If there was a guy and two robots in the bottom right of the screen mocking it, I'd see that version. The only way to save this one would be to change the puzzle which would require a massive rewrite, which would make it a different movie than the book
Any additional comments?
The only reason I didn't give it one star across the board was that some of the character interactions were good and the narrator didn't read the whole thing in monotone.
1 of 2 people found this review helpful
Narrator was not right for this book. He did the Inspector's voice like a Scottish brogue ( at least I think that's what he attempted) . It was very hard to understand. Story was ok...not my favorite.
0 of 1 people found this review helpful