Regular price: $20.65
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.65
I really tried with this. I presume someone thought about the phrase 'fuming with anger', thought that would be a cool metaphor for sin, then read a lot of Dickens. It's written in a sort of Dickensian style, but this means a lot of passive voice and far far too much detail - people don't jus get up and leave, they rise and the rooms are left, with a passing reference to the wainscotting - until you're screaming 'oh do get on with it!' The main obsession with smoke and sin becomes quickly ridiculous - every one is twisted, everyone is dirty, it's all grim - and the three main characters are stunningly unsympathetic and dull. There is an attempt at steam punk sensibilities, but it was all lost in the smog for me. Not for me, though I imagine if it's your sort of thing, then it will keep you going till the end.
What made the experience of listening to Smoke the most enjoyable?
I thought the narrator really brought the story alive - he was excellent.
What did you like best about this story?
I liked the relationship between the 3 main characters and how much they supported each other through everything.
Which scene did you most enjoy?
When Livia kisses them both right at the end.
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
Not really, although the bits with Mowgli were very sad.
Any additional comments?
This is one of those books that I think is even better to listen to than to read; the narration really brings it alive. Brilliant!