Regular price: $27.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $27.99
Anchee Min allows the reader to step right into the world of these 2 young women from different cultures. The reader is flooded with sensory information as well as temporal events. There is no criticism of either way of life which is refreshing... merely an acceptance of difference. Elegant and Evocative. I was dismayed when I finished the book. Highly recommended reading.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful
I have always been interested in Pearl Buck and this story, told from a Chinese viewpoint was enlightening. It moved slowly in places and the semi-accent of the narator was a bit ponderous. I especially enjoyed leaning about the situatiopn of the peasents in the Mao era. Now I really want to visit Ms Buck's burial place in Pa
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
The limitations and pretensions of Ayn Rand seem to loom large over this less than weighty tome - where a large ?I said, she said? narrative section is followed by some very speculative assumptions about the specific motivations of Madame Mao - which really, although they live up fully to the received wisdom of this character really need to be explored further to confirm what basis there is in history for sounds at times to be trips to the absurd.
Chinese history as Western Soap opera follows the Russian Revolution as chat magazine as provided by the ideologically egg-bound Ayn Rand.
There are some nice touches at the end - but it all tends heavily to the melodramatic and does not satisfy. Why does this feminist-rooted writing have to be so dismissive and reductivist of one of the most fascinating characters in the most significant period of history - are we really to believe that the ?big problem? was all down to the fact that Madame Mao was jealous of the possibility of Pearl Buck standing between her husband and Richard Nixon and getting her camera time.
We?ve seen the frailties and complexities of both Mao and Nixon being put through the boil-wash surely the Madame deserves something a little more substantial that this dip in a lukewarm soft soap and defoliation....surely.