Regular price: $20.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $20.99
Between the ridiculous situation—seriously, why would a white person from the south in the mid-60’s decide to masquerade as a black person?? The character showed no motivation for this decision, nothing in her past to indicate that she was particularly enlightened about race. And then she lives for years in an abandoned house with no indoor plumbing or electricity, after having been a pampered wife of a college professor??
As if the completely unbelievable lifestyle choices of the main character weren’t bad enough, the novel goes off on tangents, giving copiously detailed descriptions of side characters that have little to no bearing on the plot, and telling weird side stories. Picaresque worked for Cervantes. Zink is no Cervantes. Cervantes knew what Don Quixote was about and had a through line, but Mislaid lurches from one thing to the next with no connectivity. One minute the protagonist is making money packaging drugs, then she’s suddenly trying to sell a play that she wrote. Then the boy next door is admiring her typewriter, then a second later the reader is treated to a bunch of weird details about the political views of that boy’s parents. This book never decides what it is about. Being accepted as a lesbian? Being a gay man? Being Black? Abortion? And the less said about the actual writing, the better. Here’s just one example of the dullness of the writing:
“That fear … served to mask a deeper fear, one she never feared consciously because it was unfearable.” Worst. Sentence. Ever.
I made myself read the entire thing because it was for my book club. And then, of course, I couldn’t make it to book club.
[I listened to this as an audio book performed by Cassandra Campbell. I found her reading uninspired.]
10 of 10 people found this review helpful
Excellent, fun and entertaining book whose depth creeps up on you in the best possible ways. Nell Zink is a brilliant writer who is smart enough to poke fun at her own brilliance.
9 of 9 people found this review helpful