Regular price: $31.93
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $31.93
This was a great Halloween read/listen. The blend of Gothic ghost story, contemporary coming-of-age story, and twisty-turn mystery made for a unique mix. I also thought the narration by Emma Galvin was spot on.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful
This is a YA read, and that may be a factor in how much you like or dislike this book. I was unaware of that when I purchased this book, after the suggestion from a reader friend. I haven't read Searles before but have seen him on the Today show and know he has a big following. Generally, I don't read YA books and the fact that I continued to the end after I realized the intended audience speaks to Searles' writing talent. I wouldn't steer readers away from this choice, but I would advise them to lower their expectations.
The story has a spooky and eerie quality from the beginning. The parents were wonderfully dysfunctional; a dubious pair of spiritualist whose work is only lightly talked about with the 2 daughters, both urged to keep the family business private. Sylvie's youth has her still obedient and dependent on her parents, while her older sister Rosie is rebellious and questioning of the shady events occurring at all hours in their home. The house itself is surrounded with *no trespassing* warnings, contains a mysterious basement room, and both the artifacts from the parents *jobs* exorcising demons from the haunted, and the religious symbols of the mother's juxtaposed devotion to Christianity. The story goes back and forth between time from the night Sylvie's parents were brutally murdered to the events that led up to the crime. No ghosts, no demons, just a very strange family with a very strange business.
The story began to unravel as it spread, characters popped into the plot without clearing up any of the mystery, and even Sylvie -- whom the reader is counting on to keep us heading toward the light -- starts to become unreliable (beyond the *unreliable narrator* tactic). It is never clear if Searles intended Sylvie's memory of the events to be tinged with the recollections of a young teen, or whether Sylvie was a manipulative chip off the ol' parental block. What began as a promising haunted tale, with rag dolls fished out of wells and rocking chairs facing the corner, becomes a cloudy plot that leaves you more confused than spooked. I only hung in till the ending because I was so convinced from a great start that Searles would pull-up and give us an unexpected WOW ending -- but he didn't, and this one bombed for me.
25 of 30 people found this review helpful