Regular price: $24.47
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.47
What did you love best about Florence Gordon?
Exquisitely written, intelligent/wise book. As an audio listener, I especially liked the many short chapters.
What did you like best about this story?
Florence herself: Her toughness, self-integrity, and grit. I decided to read this because of PBS book reviewer Maureen Corrigan's description of her as a blunt and unlikeable, and I was in the mood for something unsentimental and not nicely wrapped up with a bow.
What does Dawn Harvey bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
Dawn Harvey made an ambitious effort to portray the characters with nuance. She didn't always do it perfectly, sometime blending one voice over into another, but she did capture them well.
If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?
I don't know about the tag line, but if Lena Dunham could be aged by several decades, she should play the lead.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
Would you try another book from Brian Morton and/or Dawn Harvey?
Morton yes, Harvey - not so much.
Would you be willing to try another one of Dawn Harvey’s performances?
Harvey's narration of Florence Gordon is so annoying to me that I couldn't finish the book. She has assigned "voices" to each of the characters, but Harvey can't seem to remember which character has what voice, or the voices change based on who the character is speaking to, and sometimes accents fade in and out. It was so annoying that I found myself listening to Harvey instead of listening to the characters.
Harvey over-animates the voices and turns the characters into caricatures. Florence speaks in a growly voice until Harvey forgets to maintain it, the teen granddaughter is portrayed as a stereotyped ninny, when clearly she's an intelligent and thoughtful girl.
Harvey makes all the characters overact. She should have voiced them as mature adults, using lower case tone. Instead EVERYONE IS SPEAKING IN UPPER CASE as though Harvey is trying to get a point across. No nuance.
What I like about books is you can assign or imagine voices to the characters. I love audio books, but I especially appreciate the narrators who don't try to act out the book for me. That's what my imagination is for. Just read the words, please.
Any additional comments?
I've never thought this about a book before, but I can't wait for a movie to be made. I think the it has potential to attract great actors, including older actors.
I'll be switching from audio to paper version for this book.
3 of 3 people found this review helpful