Regular price: $18.58
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $18.58
I love the series. It's been awhile but I believe the detective is a hunchback and a Catholic in the days of Cromwell. Can you tell I learned a lot? that's my brain, no reflection on the books.
I read the whole series and can't recall the specifics of this one.
narrator was good and fit the book.
Susanna Gregory is the only mystery writer who has had me simultaneously trying to suss out the bad guy while trying not to pee my pants with laughter. I don't think anyone but David Thorpe could narrate Gregory's books in quite the way he does, but his deep, slightly haughty resonance lends itself as much to intrigue as to hilarity, and at this point I only have to see the name of the author and narrator together on an audio file to lay down the cash, only there are precious few from which to choose. Pity. Get on that, Audible!! Anyway, if you like mysteries and anything medieval, get this book. Get them all, there isn't a bad one in the Matthew Bartholomew series. I particularly like how Gregory offhandedly describes what a item of clothing or food item is in the context of the time without being all education-y about it - she just says "this is what they did/ate/wore back then," gives a brief description that doesn't get in the way of the story, and gets on with it. After the book is over is when the reader (listener) learns the depth of research Gregory actually does in the weaving of her tales - many of the characters and situations in her books were real with the documentation to prove it, but have been fictionalized for maximum intrigue and entertainment. And intriguing they are. While her stories are set in medieval days, we see that human nature itself has changed very, very little since then: we are still ridiculous, hilarious, utterly foolish, and damn lucky. Many of the foibles and shenanigans that are described in this book (with hilarious detail) could just as easily have happened last week as six hundred years ago. Get this book - you'll love it. There is mystery, shenanigans, and plenty of finger-poking fun. You won't regret it.
I love David Thorpe's narration of these books and I love the way Susanna Gregory injects humor into them, they do literally a make me guffaw out loud but SO many of these books have audio problems - I have literally returned about six of them for this reason.
Either the audio skips mid sentence, or there are repeats, or the audio is very quiet and then suddenly very loud or muffled, it is a nonsense, and I have no idea why this isn't resolved as they are such popular books. They should sack the editor or production editor, whoever is responsible for checking them before the release them, it is so disappointing.
I struggle on because I love the books and also because Audible allows me to return the ones which you cannot listen to, but it really is a joke.
I also don't like the fact that, half way through the series, David Thorpe change all the characters voices. Cymric, the Welsh book bearer, who is Welsh in most of them, suddenly becomes English, Brother Michael (whose 'normal' voice I adore), becomes deep and throaty in some volumes which sounds odd when you're used to his more fey voice. I have discovered that the ones released in 2017 all seem to have the normal voices, and the earlier ones (not based on book publication but based on the audio release, the 2014 ones, tend to have different voices and accents, and this is not necessarily chronological in the series, so now I check in advance to see which year the audio was released as I got seriously muddled when he changed all the voices (Mind you, I AM easy to confuse).
But PLEASE sort out the audio problems and PLEASE also publish the rest of these books.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
The narration was very poor by David Thorpe, Andrew Wingate is far better narrating Susanna Gregory/Bartholomew books.
I was very disappointed and will be returning this book to Audible.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful