Regular price: $39.92
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $39.92
I have been a Joyce Carol Oates fan until now but will certainly have to be convinced of the value of any future books. The characters are superficial, the ?heroine could be autistic, borderline, schizophrenic or just badly behaved and selfish - but her upper-middle-class parents don't bother to have her assessed and/or treated. The structure of the book is no structure - it wanders all over the place with the voices of the individuals providing a confusing mish mash of points of view and life experiences - not to give it away but there is the human cost of U.S. wars, alcoholism, cancer, violence, confused sexuality, mental illness, poverty, affluence, an evil potential mother-in-law, religion, a questionable legal system and an individual able to influence politicians, many philosophical references and altogether too much fainting. The narration has been poorly edited with much repetition, and script-induced pseudo-hysteria. There are grammatical errors and misuse of words which could be either the author's or the narrator's problem. I could believe that this was written by someone else. It was a lot of time to waste in hope of improvement.
5 of 5 people found this review helpful
What disappointed you about Carthage?
Same incident rewritten 7 times from supposedly different points of view. The entire Part 1 could be deleted. NONE, not one of the characters elicited empathy or understanding. Least of all the missing girl - sounded like an awful, selfish, shallow girl. Cressida may be an uncommon name in the US but not in Europe.
VERY disappointed in Joyce Carol Oates. I kept hoping something would happen, or the people would get more interesting. Nope.
Oh yes, the entire part with the eccentric professor in Florida & Cressida's internship might as well be deleted too. Didn't connect to any other part of the book.
Nothing made sense.None of the people made sense. There was no story.
Would you ever listen to anything by Joyce Carol Oates again?
Not anything new. Some of her old books were good.
What didn’t you like about Susan Ericksen and David Colacci ’s performance?
Droll. Dull. Monotonous.
What character would you cut from Carthage?
Any additional comments?
Still can't believe how bad this book is!
3 of 3 people found this review helpful