Regular price: $6.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $6.95
It's difficult to find good fiction stories on the American civil war era. When I came across this book, I thought I had finally found what I was looking for: A variety of short stories about all sorts people who's lives are influenced by the war.
Unfortunately, I was wrong.
The stories were, piece by piece, incredibly mediocre and predictable with no exciting twists or surprises. They might be more suited for a younger audience to, perhaps, spark their interest in this part of history in an easy accessible way, but that is all it's good for.
A good example of this was the story about a drummer boy; told from the point of view of his dog. ("My life's purpose has just taken on a whole new meaning! I wasn't just here to protect my master, I now had a whole company of men! They WANTED me. They NEEDED me. They ACCEPTED me. I belong with my master and was happy to be here as their mascot!")
... yawn. I bet the 10-year old me would have enjoyed this.
If you are looking for a more fact-based, intriguing, thought-provoking piece of fiction and want to catch a glimpse of what life might have been like during that era for people of all sorts of different backgrounds... This book is not for you.
The narrator's performance was, on top of the characterless stories, below average. His way of reading reminded me of a young father trying to read their kid a bedtime story. His voice wasn't BAD but he gave no indication whatsoever that the story had ended. I often found myself double-checking to see if there was something wrong with my audio.
Don't buy if you are looking for something serious or enthralling. There are better alternatives out there.
What did you love best about Brother Against Brother?
The book was written around the civil war but not really about the war itself. The main thrust of the book are stories about the people, Some the soldiers, wives, sweethearts and husbands.
Some of the stories are sad and others will make you smile; for instance one about a boy and his drum that seems was as big as he was
What other book might you compare Brother Against Brother to and why?
Band of Brothers as it was about people, loyalty, duty and friendship given the backdrop of WW2
What about Jeremy Donahue’s performance did you like?
He gets into the stories and it was easy to sense he enjoyed reading them. He does not race through as he reads but keeps a good pace thats easy to follow with ones mind eye
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
yes. Not to give it away but I very much liked the story written from the perspective of a dog that follows his master.
Any additional comments?
This book is not overly long and was very enjoyable. There is romance and heartbreak and tales of courage and duty. I think men and women will both enjoy it. Its not very violent and I would not have a problem giving it too a early teen to listen too
I was given this book to review and this my honest thoughts and opinion
Brother Against Brother
This is a collection of eight short stories (two of which were excerpts) set in the States during the Civil War period. Each story has its own characters, and its own messages. There's one message that lies all the way through: no good ever comes out of a war.
The stories present the brutality seen by the soldiers, the uncertainty and doubts of the soldiers as they enlist- not really knowing what they're getting into. Causing such heartbreak in their homes: one soldier enlists leaving his fiancé behind, others fake their age, they run away to war, run away from war and face the tough climate of poverty. Or sign on as confederates to obtain information from the other side, only to then become prisoners of war. I have to say my favourite story was that of the soldier and his loyal dog. I adore dogs, and this story was so sweet. Then there was that of a son's broken promise to his mother, which was such a powerful tale.
I don't want to get too much into the stories, since they're quite short (average length: 15 minutes, based on the audio book version). This collection was well written, you could almost envision the scenes playing out. I'd say the narration by Jeremy Donahue helped picture the stories, and gave life to the messages of each tale and obviously, to the voices of the characters.
There were sad tales, touching and heartfelt, but no profanity, graphic violence, sex. I'd say they are suited for anyone over 12 years of age.
I received this book through Audio book Boom.