Regular price: $27.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $27.99
Any additional comments?
I love museums. I wanted to love this book but the "new" curator was just too naive and such a push over. I finally had to stop listening or throw my Kindle against the wall.
2 of 3 people found this review helpful
What disappointed you about Alena?
I'm about 5 hours in, and in spite of my disappointment that, so far, ALENA is more of a tepid, often clumsy REBECCA retell (rather the homage I was hoping for), I plan to give Ms. Pastan the benefit of the doubt and read on. The big disappointment is in the performance by Carla Mercer-Meyer, and not just because I find her speaking voice grating and inexpressive. Like the book this one so closely shadows, much of the plot hangs on the unworldly nature of its unnamed main character (who is also its narrator), but in ALENA, that character is a young woman with a graduate degree in art history whose career goal is to be the curator of an art museum. It is very difficult for me to believe, however, that after six years of studying the European masters, a trip to Venice to kick off the main plot of the book plus a number of years between then and the now of the book in close association with a man whose background is anything but unworldly and who has spent a lifetime in cross-cultural navigation with great success, and our narrator as performed by Ms. Mercer-Meyer can get no closer to a passable pronunciation of the Italian master fresco artist's name than Gee-OH-TOE? Really? And it's not as if that is the only gaffe. There are scores of them. We hear reference after reference to the art and artists (and their cultures) this woman is supposed to have studied, but either through inept direction or natural ignorance, the total absence of any attempt to make is seem as if she has even a passing aural acquaintance with any language other than her own American English makes credibility practically impossible, and (is it obvious) is coloring to a major extent my 'enjoyment' of the reading.
What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)
I'll let you know.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
I'm pretty sure I've already covered that question. See above.
You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?
It has held my interest to the extent that, in spite of the dreadful narrator, I'm forging on.
Any additional comments?
1 of 2 people found this review helpful