Regular price: $11.19
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $11.19
Would you consider the audio edition of A Book of Tongues to be better than the print version?
Yes. The authors work is often over flowery and ponderous but the narraotr is excellent and makes it work.
Who was your favorite character and why?
I liked the reverend. It was interesting to witness his fall from grace.
What about Gordon Mackenzie’s performance did you like?
He has great range and adds emotional quality to the book.
Who was the most memorable character of A Book of Tongues and why?
All the characters are distinct and memorable. No one in the series is nothing less than well developed.
Any additional comments?
The big problem with the series is the sexual content. This has some of the most graphic male homosexual scenes you could find in a non-porn book. I am not talking about one scene, it is throughout this book and all the rest. The story and setting was good enough I slogged through it, but it is very likely to disturb a lot of readers. DO NOT LET ANYONE UNDER 18 LISTEN TO THIS BOOK! You have been warned. the author has a good story. Why she feels the need to devlove into porn at regular intervals makes no sense. Still it is worth a read if you can get past that.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
Would you try another book from Gemma Files and/or Gordon Mackenzie?
Yes, on both counts. The presentation is really excellent, and Gemma Files writes some amazing short stories. And one of her other books, We Will All Go Down Together, is one of my favorites.
What was the most interesting aspect of this story? The least interesting?
The characters and setting are interesting. And some of the many, many ideas had a lot of promise, and some play out nicely.The quality of writing is good.
What does Gordon Mackenzie bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
His choices in voices for each character made it easy to tell everybody apart, because everything happens so fast, it could be easy for a reader to start losing track.
Was A Book of Tongues worth the listening time?
I don't regret it, but I wouldn't do it again.
Any additional comments?
Gemma Files has some phenomenal short stories, but this attempt at a novel is just so disjointed. The pacing is odd, the plot is convoluted, and character motivations are confusing at best.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
What made the experience of listening to A Book of Tongues the most enjoyable?
I'm not surprised that the review above speculates that this novel stated out as fanfiction, as the plot contains all the erotic wish fulfillment typical of that realm. What lifts it is the quality of the writing- Gemma Files has an excellent command of the genre dialect and combines it with really tight poetic prose. The dialogue zings in the manner of a good Deadwood episode- which works well in the context of an audiobook.I really had to give full marks to Gordon Mackenzie for not only navigating some luridly vocal sex scenes but also singing western tunes and voicing a main character whose larynx was crushed in a botched hanging.The central triangle between small, violent, whoreson Chess Pargeter, fallen preacher Reverend Rook and ex-Pinkerton detective Ed Morrow really is the best part of the story. It's an erotic gay romance on an operatic scale, set within a hotchpotch Aztec-Native American--Buddhist-Christian (yeah, I know) mythological backdrop. I came to the audiobooks after enjoying reading the novels- and I can see how getting your head round the scale of the mythology might be daunting. However it makes sense in terms of strong fantasy world building- Wild West magic comes from all the competing cultures and civilizations that are thrown up against each other in this raw new country- Mexicans, Indians, hell-and-damnation Preachers and Chinese railway workers. It's hugely enjoyable to see how the author pulls all these elements together- and based on quite a lot of research, so you learn a bit! Without giving away too much, the trilogy follows a betrayal-revenge-restitution arc, so it's pretty satisfying, this first book covering the initial betrayal. As the author put it in a dedication, this is one for 'everyone else who has found themselves developing a sneaking taste for blood-soaked gay porno magic horse opera' but it does end up being greater than the sum of it's parts.
Would you recommend A Book of Tongues to your friends? Why or why not?
Erm...depends on their tastes
What does Gordon Mackenzie bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?
A lot of the characters hide their emotions under a cool, gunslinger demeanor. Gordon MacKenzie made it easier to understand the subtext without losing the insouciance.
Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
Yes....the love story is convincing, and I felt for them. Also, it has to be said...this is way more erotic than 50 Shades.
I disliked this book so much I returned it to Audible, the first time I have done that in over a year's membership of happy listening. I read reviews for Gemma Files' first Hexslinger book and it sounded right up my alley, violent Deadwood style Western, with dark, fantasy elements and the promise of sexy gay romance. Well, I was confused, disappointed and frustrated. Half the time I didn't have a clue what was going on, nor did I care much to be honest. I skimmed through chunks...all the 'supernatural shenanigans' (main character Rook's words not mine). The triangle relationship between the male leads did get my attention but that's only a small part of the story. The characters are underdeveloped, and there is just too much mumbo jumbo magic and exposition. The final annoyance is its lack of a proper ending, what you get instead is set-up for the sequel (which I have no interest in reading). I have read much better developed and more satisfying fan fiction published free on the internet, and in fact would not be at all surprised to learn this series has its origins there. At least the narration is well done.