Regular price: $17.50
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.50
This is an excellent production of a difficult poem. "The Song of Roland" combines intricate poetry with enough blood-and-guts to satisfy any fan of Homer. (More than once, a well-placed blow makes an enemy's eyes literally pop out of his head.)
The translation by Michael Newth does a good job conveying the virtuosity of the rhyme scheme, even with the poor choices for rhyme available in English. He does this by focusing on vowel sounds rather than consonants. In this scheme, "hope" would rhyme with "rope," but it would also - because of the equivalent accent and vowel sound - be considered an acceptable rhyme for "bone" and "boat." These vowel equivalencies can stretch out for 10-20 lines or more. Describing it thus, it may not sound that effective, but when you hear it, it does give the poem a steady rhythm, a sense of repetition and formal structure.
The readers, primarily Greg Marston, who does the narrative passages, do an excellent job. My one complaint about the reading, and the reason for its not quite making it to five stars, is that "choral" moments are less effective. At several points in the poem, "all the knights" or "all the Moors" speak in unison, and it doesn't quite come off; the voices are not always completely in sync.
The various sections of the poem are given clear separation with a delightful variety of music.
Best not to look too deeply into the politics of the poem. "The Song of Roland" is about as intolerantly Eurocentric as they come. If our current world situation weren't so fraught, it might be possible to consider the Moors in the poem as abstract, cartoon villains, and let it go at that. As it is, I found myself wincing at times. You definitely don't want to use "Roland" as a sourcebook for Christian/Muslim relations. But if you can temporarily set aside real-world considerations and look at the poem as if it were a medieval tapestry, it can provide a unique kind of aesthetic pleasure. This is by far the best version of the poem available on Audible.
9 of 10 people found this review helpful