Regular price: $18.59
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $18.59
Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?
Sure, I enjoyed this book and don't regret the listening time. I just won't be listening to it again. To me, a three-star review doesn't mean it's a bad book, it's just... average.
If you’ve listened to books by Charles Dickens and Geoffrey Palmer before, how does this one compare?
I have no complaints with the narrator, but he couldn't raise this above a three-star. This is Dickens going for a not-so-subtle social commentary on poverty, of course. It's just a bit heavy-handed in this one, and I finished the story not uplifted so much as feeling I'd had a narrow escape from a very, very hopeless tale. I'm sure that's what he was going for but, really? There are so many other ways to say the same thing, and Dickens does it well in other books.
What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?
Geoffrey Palmer beats the "Dickens on Dickens" version hands down, as that rendition is over the top. At least I didn't feel I was being beaten over the head with the "hopelessness" in an already fairly bleak tale.
Was The Chimes worth the listening time?
Sure, listen to it. It's, after all, NOT "A Christmas Carol," so if you need something different at Christmas, there's this. But I wouldn't recommend spending a credit on it, or spending full price.
Any additional comments?
This is NOT a bad book, how can Dickens ever be, really? But there's a whole helluva lot out there that is worth listening to. If you want something GREAT? Oh, DO get "Jacob T. Marley!" Now there's another, more delightful way to spend your Christmas!
4 of 4 people found this review helpful
This was a bit of a chore to listen to and seemed to push Dicken's political cause at bit too clumsily. I really wanted to like this and hoped it was a good fit with the Christmas Carol. It was okay at the start but then it just seemed to drag. The supernatural parts, which I guess were to be like Scrooge's visit by the 3 ghosts, weren't that great, to me. It just seemed to lack the same magic, which may explain why this book is not as popular as his others.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Firstly, superb narration by Geoffrey Palmer.
The Chimes is Dickens’ second Christmas novel & succeeded the more famous A Christmas carol.
There are some fabulous Dickens characters in this novel to rival any of his previous or subsequent books, my personal favourite being the vile Alderman Cute.
As with all the Dickens Christmas novellas, a happy ending is ensured, but boy, don’t they put the main protagonist through the ringer first !
I am a massive fan of Dickens, so my reviews of his books could be coloured with bias, but for those of you looking for a change from A Christmas carol, try the Chimes instead. This is a fantastic & warming story, a veritable championing of the underdog, a fantastic new year (this story is actually more centred around the new year, than Christmas)story in its own right.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful