Regular price: $38.47
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $38.47
Unless you are a thorough going Austen addict, this is probably not the book for you. However, if you are in the words of the Jane Austen Society of North American, a Janeite, there is much food for thought and speculation about The Watsons and Sanditon. I bought this because I had only read/listened to the fragments as parts of completions by various writers. I wanted to see what my own speculations would be without a third party present. Norma West turns in the best performance of these three works that I have heard. It is an absolute pleasure to listen to her. Her Lady Susan is the best I have heard. It is written as a series of letters, a form of novel favored by novelists of the day including Samuel Richardson, Ann Ward Radcliffe and others. Jane Austen herself helped eliminate this style of novel writing with her body of work including Sense and Sensibility; perhaps, one should say helped lay the foundations of the modern novel.
I own several completion attempts of the latter two fragments both in audio and in print. I even seem to recall a movie version of the Sanditon fragment quite a few years ago. I found Juliet Barrett's Charlotte the best of the lot. I have seen some negative comments but I frankly dismiss them as petulant or uninformed. The Sanditon fragment seems a major departure from her previous work. It is startlingly different; it is as if Austen finally knew her own power.
The fragments seem to have most if not all major characters in place and are complete enough to impute the heroines; maybe project a general direction of the intended works. One can't quite be sure about the heroes except perhaps Sidney Parker, certainly not the setbacks, misunderstandings, flaws, adventures, resolution and happy ever after can only be conjectured. The last words written by Miss Austen are included, "Poor Mr. Hollis...."
7 of 8 people found this review helpful
I had read "Lady Susan" before, and this audiobook is delightful. The reader charmingly narrates the novel, savoring every cunning thought and action of this despicable main character. It is Jane Austen at her best, skewering the pretensions of a social climber and the idiocy of those charmed by a pretty face.
The other two titles are mere fragments that Jane Austen left at her death. "The Watsons" is not JA at her best, and there isn't really enough of "Sanditon" to draw any conclusions. I wish the narrator and/or the producer had done a better job of a) distinguishing between the books (the listener is just plunged from "Lady Susan" directly into "The Watsons," obviously mid-story, with no introduction or even the title being given) and b) introducing each fragment with some information about them, such as any theories about when they were written.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful