Regular price: $14.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $14.95
What would have made Ethan Frome better?
A BETTER, MUCH BETTER READER
Would you recommend Ethan Frome to your friends? Why or why not?
I would recommend "Ethan Frome" to everyone--but NOT this audio-version of it. It is awful.
Who would you have cast as narrator instead of David McCallion?
Anybody more capable. Unfortunately, Mr. McCallion, who otherwise has a nice accent, has a terrible reading voice. The reader, when simulating/acting someone's part (esp. Frome's himself), forgets to switch back to narrator's voice and therefore the dialogues often overflow into the narrations resulting in an ugly and confusing effect. McCallion overdoes his imitations too. I started listening to this audiobook from the beginning three times! Each time I reached a saturation point (about 20 minutes into it) and could not listen any farther. Naturally, this opinion has nothing to do with the phenomenal talent of Wharton as a writer--I think she was a genius and one of my favorite of the great American classics.So, do read the book, by all means, it is beautiful: but either try a different reader (a woman, preferably) or read the hard copy.
What character would you cut from Ethan Frome?
None. Edith Wharton made no mistakes. David McCallion on the other hand....
Any additional comments?
The publisher of this edition took the liberty of opening the book with a summary of the plot! (Incredible!) If you have not previously read the book, be ready to jump out of your skin because the listening experience begins with a spoiler of unsurpassed proportions.
2 of 7 people found this review helpful