Regular price: $17.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $17.99
The first half of the book is great -- I loved it, hung on his every word. He's making great points -- kids are burdening themselves with tens of thousands of dollars in student loans, spent on earning college degrees which have no economic value. For most, they will be stuck with these loans and huge interest repayments well into middle age -- and with little real benefit. That's an excellent point, and because Ilgunas' writing style is both addictive and fascinating, it's a great listen. It's like he's talking directly to you, telling you how he got himself into that mess, and how he plans to get out.
Special kudos to narrator Nick Podehl -- the perfect voice for this book. I had to check to see if the author himself was narrating, but no. It's just very well done indeed!
But then you come to the second half....... like all converts to a new lifestyle, Ilgunas decides that what he was forced to do to repay his loans -- extreme off-the-chart thrift and Alaskan wilderness-wandering to save money -- is something that everyone should do. Must do. In fact, in everyone did it, it would cure society's ills.
His notion that everyone should take time to live alone in the Alaskan wilderness -- a much, much colder Walden Pond experience -- is that it would help people refine their life priorities and make them less vulnerable to the world of consumerism. (Ilgunas doesn't delve into the mechanics of how having "everyone" retreat to the Alaskan wilderness alone would actually work out, land-and-space wise, but he's in favor of it, anyway.) Then, without taking a breath, he goes on to pontificate about the need for maintaining -- presumably at taxpayer expense -- world-wide wilderness, so that all this would be possible. And what about the people who are too "infirm" to do such a thing? He implies there would be only a few, but for those, just the idea that the wilderness exists would be enough for them to want to pay for it.
Hypocrisy reigns. In the process of ranting against organized society in general, Ilgunas decries how society "spoiled" the pristine beauty of northern New York, building communities like the one he himself grew up in -- where he still lives, in fact, as a 23-year old moocher off his parents, eating their food, tapping regularly (if reluctantly) into his mothers bank account. All the while, he ridicules the mundane life of those who work at regular jobs to pay for mortgages, who maintain restricting ties to family and friends -- when they could be out exploring the wilderness, finding their "wild" selves. In short, Ilgunas comes off as a quasi-nutcase in his fervor for his new lifestyle.
If there is an upside to that -- I came within a hair of quitting the book, in the midst of all that self-serving arrogant nonsense -- it's that at the end of the book he admits his own hypocrisy. At least he has the capacity for honesty. In that sense, it's a better book than Barbara Ehrenreich's "Nickled and Dimed: On (Not) Getting by in America", which has a somewhat similar theme. Both books are fascinating reading, the tales of bleak poverty and extreme making-do, but Ehrenreich is much more strident in advocating her solutions. At least Ilgunas maintains a smidgen of humility.
But here's the bottom line about Ilgunas: in his unbridled passion for extreme penury -- living in a toilet-free van, peeing into a bottle, discarding waste "behind a tree", fretting over a mouse eating his food -- a life in which he literally obsesses over every cent he earns and spends, he's really no different than the people he despises so much, those who are consumed with acquiring. Whether one's obsession is doing without, or with acquiring more, one is still spending one's life consumed with THINGS.
Somehow I don't think that's what he intended.
40 of 46 people found this review helpful
Ok, first I really like Nick Podehl and I thought his narration here was good. He captured the youthful voice of the author. This was a basic straight forward reading of the book and not one of those multi voiced performances that he really excels at. But overall the reading was good.
Now, on to the book. I agree with the author that far too many young people go deeply into debt financing college educations that prepare them to do nothing post graduation. Being sensible about choosing an eduction that will provide the student with easily marketable and money making skills makes sense. It has ALWAYS made sense. This isn't new news nor is it always fun to be careful in your choices. However, this approach does offer a foothold a person can use as a starting point in building a sustainable life. The author's approach was extreme, haphazard and amazingly--blindly contradictory.
Much of the thinking made no logical sense at all. For example, how could it make sense financially to drive all the way from New York state to Alaska and the Arctic Circle to work a summer job for $8 per hour at a dive motel that everyone reviews as terrible online?? Especially when you have a better paying job at home already. This is just the beginning of the scratch your head and chalk it up to impulsive youthful--wouldn't it be fun--kind of behavior.
To me, there wasn't enough or really any Walden in this tale of stumbling bumbling debt free live in your van story. Actually, the details of life in the van are beyond cringeworthy. I guess it worked out in the end...he is after all selling books on audible. Thank goodness I borrowed this copy.
13 of 16 people found this review helpful
Always interesting to hear a person's story. Ken writes well but possibly thinks he has discovered something new. He has old fashioned prejudices and believes that it is a good thing. He possibly is more interesting to actual millennials who may be more amazed by living simply to save money. (It is possible the last statement shows my old fashioned prejudice)
I think I've listened to this about 3 times now. Very good narrator and inspiring account of modern day Thoreau living / minimalism without being preachy. Highly recommend