Regular price: $24.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $24.95
The author, John West, was Chief Usher at the White House through several presidential administrations, from Roosevelt to Nixon.
What are the key character attributes of anyone holding this job? Well, obviously, the person should be well-organised and a good communicator, but they should also be discrete and tactful, and able to be trusted to keep a secret. So can we still consider John West to be trustworthy now that he has spilled the beans, revealing the secrets of the presidents’ wives? Or do these revelations mean that trust in him was misplaced?
Somehow John West manages to tell the story while retaining his reputation as a man of discretion and honour, so we aren’t left with the feeling that this is a tacky case of Kiss and Tell.
How does he achieve this? Well, firstly, he says that his principle motive is to ensure that the lives of the First Ladies over three momentous decades are not lost to history. Secondly, he must have seen, or suspected, some scandalous behaviour going on within the White House walls, but if he did, he omits these incidents from the book. For example, he never mentions JFK’s infidelities, or any other sexual impropriety for that matter. Thirdly, without being sycophantic or bland, he manages to portray the characters of the presidents and their wives in a largely positive light. It seems as if he genuinely is telling us his story for the sake of history, and because he wants to share the interesting narrative with us, and with posterity, without resorting to scandal or gossip.
It is fascinating to be a fly on the wall, getting an insider’s insight into the characters of the World’s most powerful men and their wives, as each couple displaced its predecessor and the White House staff adjusted to their different personas. We are privileged to get intimate behind-the-scenes views of such events as the death of Roosevelt, the Cuban missile crisis and the JFK assassination.
The book has some weaknesses, but in fairness, they are probably an inevitable result of its structure and subject matter: Although the author has a masterly ability to portray the characters of the presidents and their wives, it is inevitably conveyed as a long series of anecdotes. If this was the autobiography of a great inventor or adventurer, then there might be some sense of the protagonist gradually building towards the climax of achieving their life’s goal. Whereas in this book, each presidency is a new chapter, without a sense of it building on the previous chapter’s momentum, and there is no overriding goal, because the chief protagonist is essentially a passive witness to the lives of the first families, rather than having a historically significant life of his own. So for this reason the book fails to be truly captivating.
Because of the subject matter the story also, equally inevitably, gets caught up from time to time in the details of room décor, furniture, bedlinen, etc., and so the listener can be forgiven for drifting off a little from time to time when such particulars fail to hold the attention.
But these negative aspects of the listening experience are outweighed by the positives, and the overall impression as a listener is that I’m glad John West shared his story with us.
11 of 12 people found this review helpful
Where does Upstairs at the White House rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
So far, it's Number 2. Excellent book, great narration, fascinating material. It was one of those that grab you by the collar and just yank you in before you even know it.
Who was your favorite character and why?
I enjoyed the author's enlightenment on the First Ladies. Very interesting.
What about Eric Martin’s performance did you like?
Seemed real, not memorized or even read, really.
Any additional comments?
It really peaked my interest, and I'll be looking for other books of a similar nature.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful