Regular price: $15.98
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $15.98
Although this book might broadly be classified as 'true crime', it is so much more. It is the intriguing story of a life but it is also a social history. It is both tragic and inspirational, but to say more would necessarily include spoilers which would be particularly ruinous in this case because the outcome is so unexpected. The book is beautifully and sympathetically written, and I became more deeply fascinated as the story unfolded. The best is at the end, a very moving conclusion to a most unusual story. As for the narration, I was unsure of Jot Davies' style to start with, but very quickly became a fan - his timing is spot-on, he captures changing moods, and he is superb with accents and voices and foreign words - I'm keen to hear more from him.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
The book starts with the facts of a relatively straightforward, notorious crime in which Robert Coomes, a disturbed 13 year old, murdered his mother in 1895. The same story is repeated with some extra material during the Coroner’s investigation, in the Magistrate’s and Crown Court cases, becoming somewhat tedious with reiteration.
The title of the book gives the impression that this would be an investigation into a crime, but this is far from what is presented. The story of the crime is too slight to merit a whole book, but the author has done an immense amount of research into the criminal justice system, education standards and the social, political and technological history of the era and incorporated a great deal of this into the narrative. I found most of this peripheral material interesting, but was irritated by the excessive amount of irrelevant stuff such as the addresses, martial status, number and ages of children, past employment, and attire of many people who only appear for a few sentences in the book.
There are also long passages of psychological speculation and descriptions of psychiatrists’ theories of the time without much evidence of the relevance to the case. After the judgement and Robert’s committal to Broadmoor the author, having got access to the contemporary files of the institution, incorporates details about other patients that had little to do with Robert's story. By the end of the book one is left still uncertain why Robert murdered his mother.
Robert’s life is followed into the 20th century and the last hours of the recording have long descriptions of conditions during the Boer and First World wars, and rural life in Australia, followed by a long epilogue by the author that repeats some of the details of the crime and describes her labours in getting all the extra material that fleshes out the novel.
I found the book interesting but felt that the author, having done so much research, could not resist incorporating too much of it into the narrative.
The narrator is excellent.
40 of 44 people found this review helpful
I am astonished at the depth of information that the author was able to gather. The most interesting part, in my opinion, relates to history and lives of the people at that time and the details of the justice and mental health systems.
7 of 7 people found this review helpful
An amazing story, inteligently and seamlessly pieced together from a lifetime of evidence, to reveal a breathtaking telling of a boy that lived an extraordinary life of mental and physical struggle.
I agree with other reviewers, the narrator is totally wrong for this kind of story.
The story itself is very interesting, and Kate sure does her research... but maybe a bit too much little detail... a few times I found myself wishing I had the actual book so I could flick past some of it. But over all a thorough and interesting history of the times and locations.