Regular price: $13.99
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $13.99
Would you consider the audio edition of The Secret Piano to be better than the print version?
No, but then I enjoy reading. I purchased this audible version on a whim. I do have an extensive audible book library (mostly on tape :-)) but I tent to read more than listen. The idea of reading the book in the house then listening to it in the car appealed to me.
The read, listen, read feature with the Kindle is amazing. The last read pointers are spot to taking you to the page or first read paragraph of the page when listening. Amazing when you think about it. But this is not supposed to be a review of Whisper Sync
What did you like best about this story?
I am not a big biography|autobiography person. Read a few in school when I had to and maybe 3 others in the last 30 years. So if your are looking for a comparative review this is not it.
The opportunity to read an uncensored account about someones experiences in another country by someone approximately my age appealed to me.
As I recall growing up the cultural revolution in China was a good thing. At least that was the common consensus in the media at the time. This book proves otherwise.
Have you listened to any of Nancy Wu’s other performances before? How does this one compare?
No, this is my first book by her. She is very articulate and easy to listen to. Definitely not the cheap pigeon English knock off other producers have used when trying to tell an Asian story.
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
You simply can not read or listing to this book without tearing up. It is a painfully unbiased account of at best brutal times in China. It would serve some people well to read it before parroting the current anti-Chinese sediment made popular by recent elections.
The author has given a large gift of herself by writing this book. And I would imaging put herself at considerable risk. For that I am extremely grateful and will try to get some of my more biased friends to read and or listen to it.
You can not get a much more extreme reaction than trying to get a red neck friend to read a book about a pianist in a commie country!
Any additional comments?
This is simply a must experience book. It has a place on the required reading list for high school. Too bad reading is no longer required in high school.
8 of 8 people found this review helpful
An interesting book, which provided me with an insight into the Communist regime in China, which I had not previously had. The parts about music were so touchingly passionate, humble, and sincere, almost reverential towards the end, that I often sat with tears in my eyes.
I did think, though, that I would've been able to appreciate it more, had I had a greater knowledge of classical music, theory, and composers.
I enjoyed the religious/philosophical comparisons, and especially the sayings of Lao Tzu and Taoism.
The narrator was really easy on the ear and I found her reading enjoyable.
A very worthwhile book I would listen to again.
15 of 16 people found this review helpful
This is a memoir of life in China during Mao's reforms and afterwards as Xiao-Mei tries to pick up the rest of her life. I found it fascinating and yet it wasn't overly sentimental. We first meet the author as a child wanting to study music. Slowly we witness the indoctrination of her mind with the beliefs of the time and see choice taken away from her. I think it's hard for a modern reader to truly understand what restrictions were in place during that period, and this memoir brings that to life. It is nice that it follows the story after the cultural revolution so we see how Xiao-Mei's experience affected her. Interesting and inspirational.