Regular price: $39.95
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $39.95
If you could sum up The All-American Boys in three words, what would they be?
Honest, Interesting, Opinionated
What other book might you compare The All-American Boys to and why?
Riding Rockets, Carrying the Fire
What does Walter Cunningham bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
Hearing Walt tell his own story, with his little inflections and snickers, along with hearing a very serious voice at times, allows you to really understand his feelings
Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?
How the early astronauts were thrust into the world of celebrity while making government pay and realizing that they could die at any time without having the benefit of anyone offering them life insurance
Any additional comments?
Walt at his opinionated best. When this book first was published in the 1970's, it was the first book to feature the astronauts as they really were. His perspective on the space program after he left where we have given so much technology to the Russians is shot from the hip and to the point. I highly recommend the audio book as well as the printed version
3 of 3 people found this review helpful
Book started out well but devolved into a personal Ragone fest including lists made rating his peers, justification of his extra marital behaviours and topped by women and blacks should not be included in the program.... add to that his own repeated sour grapes at not being selected again and how no one remembered his flight... book becomes very painful to listen to his old school bitter white man attitude.... how was this book picked for audible?
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Is there anything you would change about this book?
Plenty. Technically, the sound quality is poor and Cunningham's narration really dire. From a content point of view, I'd have omitted the material added in 2003 which deteriorates into a long, repetitive ramble.
How could the performance have been better?
I would have it narrated by a professional actor/reader overseen by a producer and recorded in a professional studio.
If this book were a film would you go see it?
Any additional comments?
As an avid follower of the Apollo program during my teenage years, I found the first part of this audiobook (the original text written in 1977) containing Cunningham’s account of Apollo fascinating. I’ve read a number of books on the program, including Lovell’s Lost Moon, Aldrin’s Magnificent Desolation and Kranz’s Failure Is Not An Option. Cunningham provides lots of interesting new facts and snippets of inside information; opinionated and outspoken, he peppers the text with candid thoughts and assessments of his fellow astronauts and the race to the moon.
What a shame he didn’t leave it at that. In 2003, he saw fit to extend the book and give us the benefit of his thoughts on the state of NASA and the space program today. Although he is surely better qualified than most of us to provide such commentary, the result, sadly, deteriorates into a rambling diatribe, getting worse the further you get. I stuck it out to the end, but after a while, it really became a challenge. For me, it began with Cunningham giving us his critical opinion of teachers in space, followed quickly by women in space and non-whites in space. While I can’t argue with him that the best person must be selected for the job in hand – especially as an astronaut – regardless of political correctness, you can’t help thinking that he’s still living in the 60’s and doesn’t realise that society (and NASA, for that matter) has moved on. Later on, we’re treated to his outspoken opinion of collaboration with the Russians, continual harping and criticism of George Abbey to mention just a few. A lot of the commentary is opinionated with little substantiation.
Cunningham uses human and technological progress together with pushing the bounds of exploration to justify continued investment in space travel, comparing the space program with the likes of Columbus and da Gama. But you can’t help getting the impression that he doesn’t seem to understand, or at least accept, that that very progress has bought with it changes in public opinion, social values and mores along with greater demands for equality. Although he mentions the role the cold war played as a major motivator in getting an American on the moon, Cunningham doesn’t seem to realise that the motivations and justifications for putting people into space have changed in the ensuing 30 years. Towards the end of the book, I got to a point where I thought, “This must be the last chapter,” only to discover another. And another. By the end, Cunningham is repeating himself almost ad nauseum and you wonder when it’s going to stop, which is a shame because the first part of the book was excellent.
The situation was surely made worse by the overall quality of the audiobook. He may have been a great fighter pilot and astronaut, but a narrator Cunningham most definitely is not. His style of reading is terribly stilted and his technique is dreadful. It might be his book, but he should never have been allowed to read it: pauses in all the wrong places, especially when confronted with words that are difficult to pronounce, mispronunciations, and misread words make listening hard going. The sound quality is very sporadic. There’s an ever-present echo together with constant “saliva clicks” and mouth sounds that makes you think that Cunningham recorded the audiobook on a portable cassette recorder in his kitchen rather than in a proper recording studio. Plus, after the first couple of chapters, the “Chariot of the Gods” style music at the end and beginning of each chapter becomes tiresome.
All in all, I wish I’d read the original version rather than listening to the extended one.
one of the best space books re American race to the moon and the men who made it happen.