Regular price: $11.38
Buy Now with 1 Credit
Buy Now for $11.38
What made the experience of listening to Giving Up the Ghost the most enjoyable?
The anecdotes from the life of Hilary Mantel that are then reflected upon by the author and placed into the context of her whole life. It is a complex book, but there is a simplicity about it that is very graceful.
What other book might you compare Giving Up the Ghost to and why?
Clearly, by my plagiarism of his title, C S Lewis' book, ' a Grief Observed'. Although Lewis is writing about the death of his wife, and his responses to it; and Mantel is writing about her never-born child, to me they are very synchronistic in their integrity and openness.<br/><br/> I did not think either wrote of raw pain, but rather of observed pain. They were able to experience and then describe an internal feeling.
Have you listened to any of Jane Wymark’s other performances before? How does this one compare?
No, I have watched innumerable 'Midsomer Murders' though. <br/><br/>In this book, I found her voice sympathetic and expressive. It told the story without being in any way obtrusive to it.
If you were to make a film of this book, what would the tag line be?
I do not think this could be made into a film. It is too intimate and inward looking. The actual story of the author's life is not remarkable and would not really make for good watching. <br/><br/>What is remarkable is how Hilary Mantel focusses on her emotional responses to the events of her life - and that is something that can only be presented in words, not pictures.
Any additional comments?
The book is complex and rewarding. It is short and beautifully crafted. <br/><br/>I think it speaks to all of us, as each one of us has had a deep loss at sometime in our lives.<br/><br/>It is important to say that such a complex book will not satisfy in a single listening/reading. There is too much in it to take in. However given its brevity it is easy to listen to a 2nd and even a 3rd time with as much interest in it as was there the 1st time.<br/><br/>
For the first part of this book I had two very strong opinions - I was impressed by how beautifully it is written, but even the best writer must have something interesting to say and I just wasn't grabbed by any of the anecdotes and incidents from Hilary's childhood. But by the time she started university I was captivated, and her experiences with the medical profession are heart-breaking and recounted with such honesty I was fascinated and felt very privileged to be witness to everything she had gone through. The middle and end made up for the beginning so, overall I'm very glad I stayed with it.
What did you like most about Giving Up the Ghost?
The author's fiercely loud and beautiful use of words. They fight brilliantly with and for a hard life.
What did you like best about this story?
It is a prismatic, not " true" version of a life in depth..but of enormous value in breaking the ice in the ocean surrounding one's own life.
Who might you have cast as narrator instead of Jane Wymark?
Sorry, but it is over acted..a terrible no, no in a memoir of significance. The person who read Mantel's short stories was more realistic in her approach.
Any additional comments?
Listen to this and enjoy.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
An often painful listen as Hilary Mantel describes a life determined by her parents' separation and life with a stepfather and then by what can only be called medical negligence and bad practice, a state of affairs not uncommon in the 60s and 70s, channelling her into the superb writer she has become. Woven through is also the sense that the boundaries between worlds and people are not as solid for her as they are for most of us. Beautifully structured and written. Highly recommended.
3 of 4 people found this review helpful