Sorted By Most Useful
By nelson r. lampert on 11-22-16
Unusual form of detective story
What made the experience of listening to The 12.30 from Croydon the most enjoyable?
The combination of a well written story and a good performance.
What did you like best about this story?
The account of the circumstances that draw the murderer committing murder, the description of how he executes his plan, the episode that makes him commit a second murder are carefully detailed. The account of his arrest and trial are also presented. Then at the end, the detective explains how he solved the problems.
What does Gordon Griffin bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
Gordon Griffin reads the story well. I imagine that if I had the book, I would have enjoyed the story but I don't have the book'.
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
A story of the murder of a rich and frail or sick old person is not uncommon. Dorothy Sayers' "Unnatural Death" and Crofts' "The Hogback Mystery" are examples that come to mind. Here the detailed account of the hard time for everyone in Cold Pickerby, and of Charles' financial difficulties from Charles's point of view make his descent to murder believable. The second murder to silence a blackmailer is logical. The explanation of the detective at the end of the book makes a satisfying end.
Any additional comments?
I should warn other listeners that I am old. I enjoy detective stories from the 1930's. I like the fact that they move slowly and carefully. If you like something fast and racy, this book won't suit you.
4 of 4 people found this review helpful