Sorted By Most Useful
By Abigail on 01-21-12
Action Packed History, Great Narration
What a fantastic story! I was sucked in from the first moment and loved following Ludlow's dynamic and likable characters. It is an incredably interesting time in rome's history as the republic breaks down, the nobility struggle with the demands of the poor and the provinces for rights and the growing threat of unified hostile tribes. The characters are on all sides and often their loyalties are divided. The scenes of battle are as compelling as the political plots. I'm not sure why there is the bad review. The narration is wonderful and I looked for other books by Boulton because I liked it so much. However, since taste differs I would urge people to always listen to the sample of an unfamiliar narrator. I thought this was a book that could reach outside the genre to those who may not be fascinated by history or ancient Rome. The author does take time to develope his characters and plot in a thoughtful way but I do not feel this slows the action, or makes the book too cerebral. It is a more intelligent page turner however, and if you are looking for a book as light as a sitcom you may be disappointed. I would highly recommend this book.
6 of 6 people found this review helpful
By Judith A. Weller on 08-06-12
An Exciting Beginning of a Great Series
This book, historically, is set in the period of early Roman Republic during the murder of Tiberius Gracchus over his land reform program. The author then combines various tales from the Illyrian wars as his setting for one of his characters. The book has two main character, Senator Lucius whom he makes the murderer of Gracchus and the great General Aulus Macedonicus who will die in a fight with Illyrians.
This books sets up the political and military adventures of the two main character and introduce what will be the stars of the later books in the series - the the sons of the Aulus and Lucius. Both men are standins for the political and military symbols of the Republics - Aulus their greatest general and Lucius the most powerful Senator.
The prolog ties Aulus and Lucius together by a visit to the Sybilline cave and a prophcy made to the two boys. This book and later books is about the fulfillment of that prophecy.
The book gives a good picture of the policial machinations in Rome of the time and how both men wielded power. The scene in the Senate where Aulus swears that Lucius did not murder Tiberius is very powerful indeed.
For the sake of the story several anachronisms are introduced. I really doubt if Aulus or any Roman General would take his wife on Campaign in Gaul. But of course this is done so that the wife, Claudia, can be captured and impregnated by the Gallic Priest Brennos and then giver birth to a major character in the laster novels. Had this happened in reality a Roman General would have killed his wife or had her kill herfself rather than bear the child of a barbarin. So I found that whole bit about Claudia and her son by Brennos truly unbelievable -- even as a plot device it ranks pretty low.
But that aside the story is an excellent set up for the following two books which deal with the offspring of these two men.
This is an exciting book and very well read. Despite the anachronisms it does not ruin the story for the reader, although I really hated to see the death of Aulus who was my favorite character..
Anyone interested in historical fiction set in Rome will not want to miss this book. What is so interesting is that so many books are set in Imperial times, it is nice to find one set in the early days of the Republic.
6 of 7 people found this review helpful
By Jonathan Daws on 01-04-15
Great start to the story
If you could sum up The Pillars of Rome in three words, what would they be?
Great story of political intrigue in Republican Rome.
Who was your favorite character and why?
Nerva. Even though he is not the most likeable, he is very interesting.
What does Nick Boulton bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
He gave a flawless performance. Great character voices and clear reading.
Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?
Not all at once, but still a gripping story.
Any additional comments?
Very good development of a broad cast of characters. While opposed to each other, you get to see their individual motivations. No character is completely good or bad.
By Robert on 12-27-11
What disappointed you about The Pillars of Rome?
This is the slowest, worst performed book I have ever tried to listen to. I wish I could get a refund it is so bad. ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ you can sleep through the soap operatic story line of droll details and conversations done in an unapologetic English dialect. Nothing redeemable in this book...Stay Away!
What was most disappointing about Jack Ludlow’s story?
SSSSLLLLLOOOOOOOWWWWWW story line with British accents and nooooo action.
How could the performance have been better?
This book should be recommended for teenage girls....pathetic
What character would you cut from The Pillars of Rome?
I would just burn the book.
Any additional comments?
Can I have that refund?
1 of 18 people found this review helpful